Print this post

Friday, May 9, 2025

Greener on the Other Side? Not So Sure

by Zev Kam, tour guide, journalist, and frequent commentator on Kan Public Israel Radio, translated by Hillel Fendel.




A Light, Encouraging View From the Lebanese Front

In the summer of 2021, less than four years ago, the soldiers of Battalion 221 of the IDF's Carmeli Brigade were on reserves duty, with the routine mission of holding a line on the Lebanese border. The troops were stationed at the time on the western side of the border line – precisely as they are now, during these five months since the ceasefire with Hizbullah/Lebanon. Aside from the location, there is nothing else of the two periods and the two stints of duty that are comparable.

Then, four years ago, what frustrated the soldiers no end, and what was their lot throughout their tour of service, was the fact that they could see Hizbullah terrorists just beyond the fence – and there was nothing they could do. The terrorists would stand with cameras and photograph the soldiers' faces, curse them, hold up middle fingers – and the soldiers' hands were tied; they could not respond.

The terrorists even built structures right on the border, from which they could peer directly into Israel – and our soldiers, again, were helpless. It was some kind of "decree of destiny" imposed by an army and its leaders that had simply become accustomed to having the enemy mock them, learn their actions and schedules, and even erect a tent within Israeli territory (!), full of weapons. And our soldiers were totally unable, by order, to do anything.

This time, now, everything is different. Every battalion soldier on reserves duty this time is experiencing something totally different – 180 degrees different. Their two and a half months on the border are ending these very days, and what they will tell you is that, first of all, there's no Hizbullah on the border. Not even one terrorist. The troops patrol the border, and even often enter Lebanese territory, and there's no trace of terrorists. The IDF is systematically enforcing the ceasefire agreement, and does not allow a thing to happen that violates it. In the world of psychology, they would say that this is a "corrective experience," helping to heal and counteract the effects of what happened back in past years – not only for the soldiers who served there, but for the long-suffering residents of northern Israel.

It's not that the enemy or its weapons no longer exist. But they are scared and they're hiding – far away from our border. Instead of mocking our soldiers, they worry now only that they will be killed. And the numbers support their fears: Ever since the ceasefire came into effect last November, the IDF has killed 140 terrorists who were about to violate the truce, violently or otherwise.

This is also not to say that Hizbullah is not trying to rebuild itself, as close to Israel as possible. They can't build real buildings, so they bring in mobile structures – caravans, or mobile homes without wheels, to try to revive the former terrorist stronghold villages. But when they do so, an Israeli drone promptly comes along and bombs it. In the town of A-Nakura, for instance, there has been barely a week when the new caravans they brought in were not destroyed. And the story was the same elsewhere as well, until finally, Hizbullah stopped bringing in caravans.

One of the more memorable aspects of the warfare with Hizbullah is the story of the "nature reserves." They're not quite reserves, but they have enough shrubbery and overgrowth that the terrorists used to be able to take cover there and even fire at the IDF forces. One day, at the beginning of the current war, some Israeli reservists actually built a Roman-style catapult and fired over some fire-torches to burn large swathes of the greenery. Of late, the IDF has continued to deal successfully with this problem, clearing very large areas in Lebanon, particularly in the areas within hundreds of meters from the Israeli border, to prevent the enemy from coming near us under the cover of green.

But of course nature continues to run its course, and the growth does what it knows how to do best: it grows. The forces tried spraying various growth-retardant chemicals, but these too were insufficient. So the soldiers of Battalion 221 became gardeners: They set out for Lebanon to trim or cut down trees, cut off branches, and basically clear entire areas practically by hand. They marched through the wadis of southern Lebanon, equipped with state-of-the-art gardening tools – thus proving that it is actually not true that the grass is always greener on the other side…  

And here's another thing that is worthwhile to know: In all the Lebanese terrorist-stronghold villages along Israel's borders that the IDF destroyed in last year's war, not one of them has begun to be rebuilt. Not one. They are simply not settled; desolate. Here and there people are seen coming to collect some of their belongings or metals for one purpose or another – but no one lives there.

In Israel, on the other hand, the residents of almost every single northern village have returned home.

No one is saying that everything is hunky-dory or that there's nothing to fear. In the town of Shlomi, for instance – a beautiful Israeli village in the northwestern Galilee, population 8,000 – they built a new school about two years ago. But then the war broke out, the town came under Hizbullah fire, and people left. Now that they have returned, the question was raised: "What do we do with the new school? After all, it's even closer to the border than the old school was!" Some parents, and teachers, were quite jittery at the prospect of holding classes there.

The security officer of Shlomi quickly called the commander of Battalion 221, Brig.-Gen. Binyamin Tropper, and asked him to explain the situation to the concerned residents. Tropper came, explained to them how the situation had been reversed, told them how many soldiers are holding the area, and provided encouraging details regarding the new circumstances.

Almost everyone was reassured – except for one teacher, who asked, "Why is the soccer field in town still not lit up? And the same for the streetlights in that neighborhood. Doesn't that mean that we're still afraid that Hizbullah will fire rockets at us?"

The mayor, who was also present, was puzzled, and asked that the matter be checked. Within minutes, it turned out that no one had turned off the lights at all. Rather, a Hizbullah rocket a while back had knocked out part of the electricity in the neighborhood – and no one paid much attention to it - probably because no one was living there for a while, having all been evacuated to "southern" Israel. The matter was quickly resolved.

This story shows that there are still fears, and no one should make light of them. But the new school in Shlomi is now open.

And for a final incident, this one a bit more amusing: Overlooking Shlomi is an IDF outpost named Magen Yehuda (Shield of Judah), the largest of five such points inside Lebanon. Though they are well-protected, they are not only for the purposes of defense. Not a day goes by that the IDF does not send forces relatively deep into Lebanese territory to search for weapons and the like left behind by Hizbullah, and in general to safeguard the area.

Every move that the Lebanese Army, or the UN forces adjacent to the border, wants to make must be closely coordinated with the IDF – and in fact this is the case most of the time. On the other hand, the IDF doesn't coordinate with anyone when it wants or needs to enter Lebanon. Whenever the security needs of the residents of the north require it, even indirectly, the troops enter Lebanon and do what has to be done. This led to an interesting ping-pong exchange with the Lebanese Army recently.

What happened was that the IDF brass decided that the buffer zone around Magen Yehuda needed to be expanded, so as to ensure that the terrorists do not try to come close. And so, one night the Israeli troops went out with metal posts, known as baznatim, and stuck them in the ground some distance away from Magen Yehuda, in order to show the locals that there was a new "border." The next morning, the Israeli cameras showed a lot of confusion. The Lebanese locals seemed to not understand what had happened while they were sleeping. Still, however, after a few days, they decided to show some muscle, and went to remove the baznatim.

For the Israelis, this was not the end of the story, but rather only the beginning. They sent another force in that very night to replace the baznatim. But the Lebanese, too, didn't give up – and thus began a ritual of them removing, and our side replacing.

Until finally one time, when the Lebanese soldiers came to uproot the baznatim, they found themselves with hands full of oil and grease – which the Israelis had spread over the posts before leaving them in the ground. This time the cameras caught the Lebanese gesticulating in frustration at the tremendous mess they had made of themselves, and at the prospect of the long showers they would have to take – if there were any in their outposts.

Yet another time, when the Lebanese tried to uproot the metal posts, all of a sudden, miraculously, light bombs exploded from within – totally harmless, but frightening just the same. Their cries of shock could be heard all the way to the new school in Shlomi - where the pupils are safely attending classes.