by Rochel Sylvetsky, Op-Editor of IsraelNationalNews.com and former Chairperson of Emunah Israel, translated by Hillel Fendel.
Israelis needn't have been surprised at the electoral defeat suffered by the Republican party in the recent American midterm elections. It was simply a repeat of what has happened in 90% of midterm elections in the House of Representatives (and 70% in the Senate) over the past century. After two years in office, the ruling party has invariably not succeeded in fully carrying out its platform, while the voting public has had plenty of time to find reasons to complain, criticize, and demand change. And despite the difficulties caused to the ruling party when they lose much of their power, this is one of the balances in the U.S. Constitution, for better or worse, that prevents one party from gaining too much power.
Not Promoting the Iran War
Still and all, it is clear that there are specific reasons for the Republicans' downfall. Notably, no PR campaign worthy of its name was waged to justify the war with Iran. Trump's advisors are no longer the measured and statesman-like Friedman and Greenblatt. Instead, some of their replacements have clear conflicts of interest regarding Qatar, and appear to want quiet at any cost; others believe that America should stop seeing itself as being responsible for the entire world (as if the danger of nuclear weapons can simply be ignored). Meanwhile, the Iranian regime exploits Western naivety, dragging out negotiations for an agreement that in any event will not be worth the paper it might be printed on. Consequently, President Trump, who fully grasps the perils of a nuclear-armed Iranian enemy, issues contradictory messages day in and day out, thereby losing the trust of the electorate.
If Trump would have continued the war and liquidated Iran's nuclear capabilities, the American public would have been thrilled and would even have accepted a temporary rise in gas prices with patriotic understanding. But he stopped in mid-war, the indecision dragged out, and the American electorate lost its patience. The lack of basic war planning boomeranged on Trump, who apparently did not foresee the Hormuz Straits issue, and the voters simply lost their patience with him and the entire MAGA campaign.
And Israel?
The midterms upset does have great ramifications upon Israel, of course – primarily in that most of the newly elected Democrats in Congress, including several Muslims, are outright anti-Semites and strongly anti-Israel. When I grew up in New York a few decades ago, candidates generally did not publicly express anti-Semitic or blatantly anti-Israel sentiments. But this is no longer the case, as can be clearly seen in the new composition of the U.S. Congress.
Whose fault is this? Some blame Prime Minister Netanyahu. For instance, here is Ariel Shenbal, writing for the nationalist Makor Rishon paper: "The policy of total reliance on the Republicans, and neglect of the Democratic side of the aisle, is 'credited' to Netanyahu … [and] has dug Israel into a deep pit."
Let it be stated clearly: Israel under Netanyahu did not choose to rely exclusively on the Republicans, nor did it ignore the Democrats. It was rather the Democrats that turned their back on Israel. It was President Obama who was the first president ever not to veto an anti-Israel United Nations resolution. And of course we can't overlook Bernie Sanders, and the Squad… The party has used anti-Zionism as a tool by which to garner the support of the younger generation and the progressives - those who grew up on a daily menu of hatred for Israel on social media and in academia, those who term Israeli defense actions as genocide, and those who refuse to recognize Hamas as the brutal, terrorist organization it is.
Members of the "anti-Bibi" bloc consistently argue that Netanyahu is to blame for the widespread criticism of Israel. Yair Lapid, for instance, has been spending considerable time in the U.S. attempting to assure everyone that Israel will soon have a new, anti-Bibi leadership that will allow America to draw closer to us once again.
But they are wrong; it has nothing to do with Netanyahu. Jonathan Tobin, former editor of the prestigious Commentary magazine, and founder and chief editor of JNS (Jerusalem News Syndicate), wrote recently precisely to this point. Excerpts thereof:
"It’s not about Netanyahu: Many Democrats claim to still support Israel. But the list of those who are willing to emphatically refute the anti-Semitic lies about the Gaza war … are now few and far between. Few oppose restrictions or bans on military aid to Israel in wartime or sanctions against Jews in Judea and Samaria, who have been demonized by the false narrative of “settler violence.” … Moreover, the notion that the Democratic Party’s turn against Israel can be explained by being alienated by the policies and statements of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is a myth.
"Pro-Israel Jewish Democrats claim that Netanyahu has destroyed Democratic support for the Jewish state by favoring Republicans, especially Trump. But this is false. In the last two decades, it is the Democrats who have turned on Israel - not just Netanyahu - by embracing appeasement of Iran and clinging to the two-state solution and “land for peace” formulas that most Israelis rightly understand as merely a recipe for more Oct. 7-style terror atrocities, not an end to the conflict.
"If anyone still doubts that, they need to read the exchange on X between Israeli opposition leader Yair Lapid and Brad Lander, the Democrat who was just elected to Congress from New York City … Lander responded with scorn to Lapid’s expectation that a change in power in Jerusalem and more outreach from Israeli leaders like him, who are eager to be friends with the Democrats, would change things.
"He made it clear that Democrats like him, who are allied with the anti-Semitic New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, and even others who are not that extreme, aren’t interested in mainstream Israeli opinion, even when it comes from liberals who want to be his allies.
"…At a minimum, he’s demanding withdrawal from Judea, Samaria and Jerusalem and the creation of a Palestinian state, likely run by Hamas, that would pose a deadly threat to Israel’s existence. That’s something that not even the left-leaning “anyone but Bibi” coalition could possibly accept."
This change in the Democratic party didn't happen overnight, nor is it because of us. Firstly, Islamic influence in the government is increasing, and anti-Zionism is gradually becoming the norm among the Democrats, for whom all means are legitimate in order to secure the support of progressives who protest in favor of Hamas and against Israel. The ascent of the progressives and woke ideology has been companied by a hatred for the State of Israel. What began as a slight dent in the Democrats' traditional pro-Israel stance, has become a strong current of not a few Jewish (or Jewish-identifying) liberals.
In my parents' day, Jews supported the Democrats as representing new immigrants and traditional liberalism, while the Republicans stood for the upper classes. This has long since been reversed, but most non-religious Jews are in any event more concerned with civil rights around the world and less with the plight of Israel about which they hear only false allegations.
Neither Eisencott nor any of his anti-Bibi allies would dream of fulfilling the suicidal demands that the Democrats are presenting to Israel, and therefore they, too, will not earn their support of love. It truly has nothing do with Netanyahu - and the sooner we all internalize this, the better.
