Showing posts with label Rabbi Danny Lavie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rabbi Danny Lavie. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Dangerous Enemy in Our Midst

by Rabbi Danny Lavie, head of Olamot and rabbi at the Elon Moreh Hesder Yeshiva, translated by Hillel Fendel.




Whose words are these? "It's only a matter of time until the fifth column living in Israel, that which benefits from and takes advantage of Israel's democracy while essentially opposing Israel – rebels against the State… Israel must be prepared and united, because the most dangerous enemy is the one within."

They were stated by Mas'ab Hassan Yusuf, who grew up in Gaza as the son of one of the founders of Hamas. His words echo very strongly on the backdrop of the unprecedented achievements of the Arab parties: 19 seats in the Knesset, nearly a sixth of the total.

Those who say that perhaps he is exaggerating and that the Arabs actually love living in Israel – are simply blind to the essential Palestinian identity that truly defines them. The source of this blindness is rooted in the liberal-secular outlook that assumes that people everywhere are motivated by the same material needs, no matter their religion or ethnicity. All they want is personal freedom and economic security, it is felt, and if they achieve this, their nationalistic ambitions will fade away. 

This, of course, is the same misconception that brought us the Simchat Torah massacre: "If we just give livelihood to tens of thousands of Gazan workers by letting them enter Israel every day, Sinwar would have no interest in attacking us." Yeah, right.

A Muslim researcher concluded: "No suicide terrorist aged 18-38 [in our study] fit the typical profile: None of them were uneducated, indigent, unintelligent, or oppressed. Many of them were of the middle-class and held good jobs, and two of them were sons of millionaires."

This helps clear up why the great conditions to which the Muslim immigrants in Europe were treated has not stopped them from seeking to harm their host countries and populations.

The misconception of "economic peace" is also a reason why the dangerous rise of the proportion of Arab doctors in Israel continues apace – easily presenting a potentially grave security problem in the future.

Telling It As It Is

Six years ago, we abruptly awoke to a very unpleasant "surprise" – Israeli-Arab riots and lynches in some of our mixed Jewish-Arab cities, such as Lod and Jaffa. Yet, the handwriting had been on the wall well before. Three years earlier, TV presenter Yaron London spoke to Arab-Israeli high school students, and one of them told him to his face < https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nm_1rhlWI-U>: 

"One of these days, we will be the majority here, and this Jewish state won't be here anymore – and then, wow, what will happen to you… This state will be ours, it will return to be ours. This is what we were all brought up on…"

Surveys and polls consistently find that a solid majority of Israeli-Arabs negate Israel's existence as the national state of the Jewish People. Most support the "Right of Return" [of millions of Arabs to their pre-1948 homes in Haifa, Ramle, etc.], and an increasing number define their identity as "Palestinian." 

It must be made clear that this is not an issue of racism. Rav Kook, for instance, viewed the presence of non-Jewish minorities under Jewish sovereignty in a positive manner. Rather, the issue is the presence of a growing minority that does not accept Israel as a Jewish State and identifies and supports its enemies.

In Europe, well-founded accusations of systematic Muslim crimes, including rape, have long been considered "Islamophobic." Look where that has gotten them! Real facts on the ground don't take political correctness into account, and in fact are blowing up in Europe's face. The same danger could very well be soon facing us here in Israel. 

The election results of two weeks ago – to reiterate: 19 Arab MKs (!) – show that Palestinian identity, which the two Arab parties that won seats proudly boast of and promote, is the mainstream in the Arab-Israeli public today. These parties even refuse to call Hamas a terrorist organization! 

And now there is talk of forming a government that would rely, if only passively, on Arab-Israeli support. This, even though the new Arab MKs who met with President Herzog last week acknowledged to him that even if they were members of an Israeli government, they could not guarantee their electoral support for a government-declared war against Hamas or Hizbullah. 

Democracy on the Defense

Israel's Supreme Court has had a strong hand in the growing Arab influence in Israeli politics. This cannot go on; we cannot allow our democratic formalities to pave the way for our self-destruction. Note that back in 1965, when the Arab "Socialist List" party supported Palestinian rights and a bi-national state instead of a Jewish one, it was actually banned from running for the Knesset. Supreme Court Justice Yoel Zusman explained then: "Just as a person need not agree to be killed, a state, too, need not agree to be erased from the map."

And in fact, Clause 7a of the "Basic Law: The Knesset" explicitly states that a list or a candidate that denies the existence of Israel as a Jewish and democratic state, or supports the armed struggle of a terrorist organization, shall be disqualified from running for the Knesset. The problem is, however, that the Supreme Court, time after time, has overturned rulings to this effect by the Central Elections Committee, and allowed terrorist-supporting parties to run. This is a double injustice: The Court thus allows enemies to take part in making decisions for Israel's future, and also thwarts any chance for alternative Arab parties to gain support. 

The Solution

What is the solution? To maintain our democracy, we must adapt the rules of "defensive democracy," as is already the case in other countries. In 2003, Spain outlawed the Basque "Batasuna" party for refusing to condemn the attacks of the ETA underground. This decision was upheld unanimously by the European Court of Human Rights, setting a critical precedent for our situation: Refusal to condemn terrorism is equivalent to active support for terrorism. This is exactly how we must act here too, leaving no room for judicial discretion. 

In addition, supervision of education in Arab society must be particularly strict, and decisive action must be taken against anything indicating support for undermining the State's existence.

Biblical precedent is quite germane here. At first, Yishmael sought to undermine Isaac as Abraham's successor and heir, and Abraham and Sarah dealt with him with a strong hand. In the end, Yishmael repented of his deeds and even showed honor to Isaac (see Genesis 25,8-9). Yishmael has a place in this Land – as long as he defers to Isaac, the Jewish People, as the sovereign power.

If we do not employ a clear-eyed perspective and decisive action against those who undermine the State of Israel, we will simply worsen the situation and increase the danger. These recent elections could be a watershed moment regarding Arab society, if we choose not to continue to close our eyes. Only by drawing a clear boundary between loyal citizenry and an enemy from within, can we guarantee the existence of the Jewish state for generations to come.